B"H
Were the fifth Lubavitcher (Chabad) Rebbe Shalom Dov Ber Schneersohn (1860 - 1920) and his only son, Rebbe Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn (1880 - 1950, the father - in - law of the last Lubavitcher Rebbe Menachem Mendel Schneerson), sexually abused in their childhood ?
Did Rebbe Shalom Dov Ber travel to Vienna in 1903 in order to consult Sigmund Freud and get over his trauma ?
"Failed Messiah" claims to have an answer.
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
B"H
ReplyDeleteI have received some e - mail comments on this saying
1. That it is NOT true
and
2. Even if it is true, we will never know for sure, as Chabad will not provide any information.
I have read that famous article and there are many mistakes that indicate that the story may be untrue.
ReplyDeleteB"H
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with that and don't think the story is true. Whoever does research and finds something out would never ever make such mistakes !
HOW CAN ONE EVEN POST SUCH A THING?
ReplyDeleteTo trust the testimony of some sheygetz about Rebbeim?
B"H
ReplyDeleteI don't like the approach of the Failed Messiah either and think that it is totally crazy only to look at the negative side of haredi society.
However, Chabad has been covering up some Rebbe relatives becoming secular or converting to Christianity as well as one brother of Rebbe Menachem Mendel Schneerson who was mentally ill and killed by the Nazis.
what one thing has to do with the other I have no idea...
ReplyDeleteHaving read the article it would seem that the idendity of the Rabbi treated by Dr Stekel was probably Rashab. There are far too many similarities to what is known about his condition for this to be a co-incidence. There are a couple of minor inconsitencies but these can be easily explained.
ReplyDeleteAs for Feivel's racist comment; the doctor that treated Rashab and the author of the article are Jews
Shmarya may be a Jew but his hate-spewing mirrors that of racist non-Jews. Anyone whose mission in life (and he does devote almost all of his life to his blog) is to dig up all the dirt he can about Charedim should not be given any acknowledgment in our society.
ReplyDeleteIts safe to say such an article is Sheker. Why?
ReplyDeleteBecause how could it be that in the past 100 years something such as this could have been covered up when there have been so many groups that have made it their lifes mission to expose and destroy Chabad.
But in the 21st century arose a man. a jew! a fried out bitter ex Lubavitcher who will stop at nothing to destroy Chabad because his feelings were hurt.
He above all else is able to probe into the depths of Chabad and weed out the evil inside that was untouchable till then.
yaaaaawn. Sounds like a Hollywood blockbuster.
anyways. Hes a Rodef. Let me have his little blog and be counted on the Forward top 50 most influential Jews. Such accomplishments.